Update Regarding North Carolina Court of Appeals' First Appellate Decision on Extended Benefits Beyond 500 Weeks

In the last few weeks, the North Carolina Court of Appeals issued (the MGC update can be found here) and then quickly withdrew (the MGC update can be found here) its precedential ruling in Sturdivant v. NC Department of Public Safety (COA22-421), which set the standard for assessing extended TTD benefits claims wherein the claimant is seeking compensation past 500 weeks. The Court did not provide an explanation for its withdrawal of the original decision. They have now re-issued an amended decision in the case.

Review of the amended decision shows that no changes were made to the actual holdings in the case. Therefore, the Court’s ruling on handling extended TTD benefits cases has not changed—the standard for establishing disability is the same both prior to and after 500 weeks. The traditional Russell factors will remain the standard for assessing disability, even beyond 500 weeks. A claimant seeking extended benefits is not entitled to a presumption of disability when seeking benefits beyond 500 weeks.

The case remains one of first impression. MGC will continue to provide updates as to whether it is appealed further. Please do not hesitate to contact one of our North Carolina worker’s compensation attorneys with any questions or concerns.

This legal update is published as a service to our clients and friends. It is intended to provide general information and does not constitute legal advice regarding any specific situation. Past success does not indicate likelihood of success in any future legal representation.

You may not reproduce, distribute, sell or republish this legal update, or the information contained therein, without prior written content. This legal update is for personal use only.